A new, "unique" method of dismissing claims has emerged in judicial practice. The essence of this method is simple: completely ignoring the arguments presented by the plaintiff and their representative. Turning a blind eye to them and remaining silent. Even if you repeatedly write out your arguments in the complaint, the result does not change. What the law says or what is explained in the decisions of the Plenum of the Supreme Court seems to be irrelevant.
To ensure my words are not unfounded, I will give one specific document as an example. This is a ruling issued by Supreme Court judge M. Rabiyeva on November 13, 2026. By this ruling, the refusal to transfer a cassation appeal to the Civil Cases Judicial Board of the Supreme Court regarding civil case No. 2-2001-2608/87 was upheld.
What the Case is About
Plaintiff U.B. worked as the head of the Bukhara branch of the state institution "Uzbekistan National Institute of Metrology" for nearly five years. In April 2025, the employment contract was terminated based on his application. The plaintiff states that he wrote the application trusting the employer's promise to provide another job after two months. When the promise was not fulfilled, he applied to the court asking for reinstatement.
The Bukhara Interdistrict Court dismissed the claim on March 26, 2026, due to the expiration of the limitation period. The appeal (July 7) and cassation (October 5) instances of the Navoi Regional Court left this decision unchanged. The Supreme Court judge, in turn, refused to transfer the complaint to the judicial board.
The Ruling Contradicts Its Own Conclusions
The most interesting thing is that reading the ruling is sufficient. The facts presented in it contradict the conclusion reached.
First. The ruling states that the order was approved by the employer's electronic digital signature on April 21, 2025. The same ruling states that the plaintiff was familiarized with the order on April 18, 2025. How can one be familiarized with an order that has not yet been approved? There is no answer to this question in the ruling.
Second. The ruling refers to Article 560 of the Labor Code. According to it, the period is calculated from the day the copy of the order is delivered. However, the case file contains only a receipt stating that he was "familiarized" with the order. Exactly when and to whom the copy was delivered is not indicated in the ruling.
Third. According to the conclusion of the Samarkand interregional department of RSEM dated June 22, 2026, the handwritten notes regarding the order on the receipt do not belong to the plaintiff. This conclusion is cited in the ruling itself. Nevertheless, the court took this very receipt as the basis for the start of the period. Even when the expert conclusion is in favor of the plaintiff, it is not evaluated.
Fourth. The employment record book was collected not by the plaintiff himself, but by another person on the basis of a power of attorney on April 23, 2025. This circumstance also does not prove that the plaintiff personally received a copy of the order.
Fifth. The plaintiff's main argument is that the application was written trusting the employer's promise, meaning it was not voluntary. This argument is also directly related to the issue of reinstating the term with a valid reason. There is not a single sentence about this in the ruling.
"Studied and Properly Evaluated" — A Standard Template Instead of an Answer
All arguments in the complaint are "answered" with a single sentence in the ruling. It states that the arguments "were studied by the regional court's cassation instance and proper legal evaluation was given to the court documents." It is neither stated which argument was studied how, nor why they were found to be groundless.
In this situation, each instance refers to the previous one. The district court relies on the deadline. The appeal court upholds the district court. The regional cassation instance upholds the appeal. And the Supreme Court judge simply adds that "the regional court has studied it." As a result, no one actually examines the plaintiff's arguments on their merits.
The Civil Procedure Code requires that a court document be reasoned. If the parties' arguments are rejected, the reasons for their rejection must be indicated. The Plenum of the Supreme Court has also repeatedly explained this to the courts. Failure to evaluate an argument remains in practice a form of evaluating it. Only this evaluation is based on convenience rather than the law.
This is Not Just a Single Case
Such rulings erode citizens' trust in the court. A person writes out their arguments, collects evidence, conducts expertise, and goes through several instances. In the end, they receive no response to any of their arguments. In this situation, the court ceases to be a means of protection and turns into a mere formality.
Therefore, I consider the following to be necessary:
The Chairman of the Supreme Court should study the practice of issuing template rulings without evaluating arguments and give clear instructions on this matter.
The High Judicial Council should take special control over the issue of the justification of court documents.
The Qualification Board of Judges must take measures provided by law against judges who deliberately ignore the law and the explanations of the Plenum.
There is a right to file an application against this ruling to the Chairman (Deputy Chairman) of the Supreme Court demanding its cancellation, and we will use it. However, the issue is much broader than the scope of a single case. If the court does not hear the argument, it does not hear justice either.
Shavkat Mavlyanov, lawyer




