Dark mode
Society

School controversy in Bukhara: department claims students did not carry desks, but videos show the opposite

Akmal Eshonxonov39 views
School controversy in Bukhara: department claims students did not carry desks, but videos show the opposite

Earlier, our editorial office published videos showing students of general secondary school No. 42 in the city of Bukhara carrying desks and chairs on their day off. This situation caused public outrage. Following this, the Bukhara regional Education and Science Department issued an official response regarding the incident.

According to the department, the technical condition of the school building, constructed in 1958, has deteriorated sharply. There is also a shortage of study places in the educational institution. A letter dated November 9, 2026, from the regional inspection for control in construction and housing-communal services of Bukhara region notes that the school buildings were found unfit for use and recommendations were given to ban their use.

In this regard, it is planned to continue the educational process in the vacant buildings of school No. 44 and the Bukhara Law College. The department stated that technical staff and parents volunteering to help participated in moving the equipment, and students were not involved in the process.

However, in videos and photos provided to the editorial office by parents, students can be seen lifting and carrying desks and chairs. This process did not happen on a school day, but on a weekend — Saturday and Sunday. The day before, that is, on Saturday, school desks and chairs were moved all day and they were called in for Sunday as well. When the children came home on Saturday and parents asked why they were late, they said that moving work was taking place at the school and desks and chairs were being carried. The next day, parents went to check whether their children actually went to school, were carrying desks and chairs, or went somewhere else, and witnessed this situation. Thus, a discrepancy arises between the information in the department's official response and the situation visible in the images.

Notably, the department specifically emphasized in its response that ensuring the safety of students' life and health and maintaining the continuity of the educational process is a priority task.

Well, if the life and health safety of children is truly a priority, why did they participate in the process of carrying heavy school equipment? Given that there are staff technical personnel at the school, what was the reason for assigning such tasks to students? How was the children's safety ensured during this process?
What does the Labor Code say?

Article 5 of the Labor Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan prohibits forced labor. It defines forced labor as any work or service demanded from a person under the threat of punishment, where the person has not offered their services voluntarily.

According to Article 118 of the Code, employment is allowed from the age of 16. Students who have reached 15 years of age may be involved only in light work that does not harm their health and educational process during free time from studies, with the written consent of one of the parents.

Article 354 of the Labor Code prohibits involving persons under 18 years of age in heavy work, and work with harmful and dangerous working conditions. Cabinet of Ministers Resolution No. 290 dated July 14, 2023, approved the list of heavy work and work with harmful or dangerous working conditions where the labor of minors is prohibited. Specific standards have also been established regarding heavy loads that employees under 18 years of age can lift and carry.

In the situation at school No. 42, the age of the students, the weight of the equipment they lifted, the conditions during the work process, and how the children were involved in these tasks determine the legal aspect of the matter.

So far, the department has not provided a separate comment on the images showing the participation of students. It also remains open who was responsible for the equipment relocation work and whether an internal investigation was conducted regarding this situation.

It is important that the protection of children's life and health is fully ensured not only in official statements, but also in practical processes. Therefore, it is appropriate for responsible agencies to provide an unbiased comment on the situation shown in the videos, clarify whether students were involved in carrying equipment on their day off, and give a legal assessment of the situation.

At the same time, we await an official response from the Minister of Education Erkinjon Turdimov regarding this situation and announce that our editorial office will send a journalistic inquiry on this matter.

Share:

Related News

School controversy in Bukhara: department claims students did not carry desks, but videos show the opposite | Effect.uz